TL;DR: The unsupervised take-home test stopped measuring developer quality once 97% of developers started coding with an AI assistant. Verify identity first, then score judgment over output: how the candidate routes work, what they check before shipping, and how they write when nobody is on the call. Finish with a paid trial, which is the one signal AI cannot fake for you.
Remote developer hiring broke in a specific way over the last 18 months. Gartner now projects that one in four candidate profiles worldwide will be fake by 2028, and 97% of developers already code with an AI assistant.
About 8% of applicants clear our full screen, and the stage that eliminates most of them is no longer the coding test.
We worked with a Series A startup that hired three remote developers in two months. One stayed past 90 days. Their evaluation process was fine for 2021 and useless by the time they ran it.

| Evaluation Method | What It Measured in 2021 | What It Measures in 2026 | What to Do Instead |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unsupervised take-home | Coding ability | Prompting ability, or nothing | Keep it, then defend it in a live walkthrough |
| Algorithm puzzle | Raw problem-solving | Whether they memorized the pattern | A task from your real backlog |
| Polished README | Written communication | Access to a chat model | Live written answers under observation |
| Resume and profile | Work history | Little, until identity is verified | ID check plus a live camera-on session |
| Paid trial project | Real performance | Real performance | Keep it, and weight it heavily |










