By Eric Cheng, Head of International Business
19 min read
TL;DR: Arc.dev publishes its prices: freelancers at $15 to $110+ an hour, or a one-off fee of 20% of the annual salary for a full-time hire. Toptal publishes a $79 monthly subscription, quotes the talent’s rate on a call, and says it introduces candidates within 24 hours. Pick Arc for listed fees and a full-time option, and Toptal for a fast shortlist and the right to trial up to three candidates per role.
Both companies screen remote talent before you meet anyone, and both say only a few percent of applicants get through. Arc says 2% pass its technical interview, and Toptal accepts fewer than 3%.
They part ways on price and on what a hire is. Arc prices freelance and full-time hires on one page. Toptal sells engagements billed weekly, at rates you get on a call.
Key takeaways
1Toptal’s first stage cuts hardest: only 26.4% of applicants pass its English and personality interview. Arc’s first stage lets 55% through.
2On a $90,000 salary, an Arc full-time hire costs a one-off $18,000 fee. Toptal publishes no equivalent figure.
3Toptal says 90% of clients hire the first candidate it introduces, and lets you trial up to three candidates per position.
4Arc backs full-time hires with a free replacement for three months. Toptal’s cover is a no-risk trial of up to two weeks.
Arc.dev vs Toptal vs Second Talent for a US startup
For a US startup, the useful comparison is the monthly bill for one engineer and the hours that overlap with your team. Figures are from each company’s own pages, checked on October 12, 2026.
For a US startup
Arc.dev
Toptal
Second Talent
Published price
$15 to $110+ an hour freelance; 20% of annual salary full-time
$79 a month subscription, plus a rate quoted per engagement
$25 to $39 an hour, billed monthly; $0 until you hire
One engineer, 160 hours a month
$2,400 to $17,600+ (freelance)
Quoted on a call
$3,999 to $5,999
Speed
Freelancer in 72 hours; full-time in 14 days
Candidates within 24 hours
A shortlist of 6 to 8 vetted profiles in 24 hours
If the hire does not work out
Trial up to 2 weeks; free re-match in the first 3 months
Trial of up to 2 weeks
90-day, one-time replacement
Overlap with US hours
Not stated
Not stated
4 to 6 hours a day
Employment and payroll
Your payroll for full-time hires
Contract engagement
Included, through our EOR in 9 Asian markets
Arc and Toptal both leave employment to you once a contractor becomes permanent. Second Talent’s rate covers the engineer, payroll and compliance, and every engineer is checked on Claude Code and Cursor during vetting.
Use Arc if you want a price before you talk to anyone, or if you want to hire someone full time and put them on your own payroll or an EOR’s. Its fees sit on one page, and the full-time fee is paid once.
Use Toptal if speed and a guided shortlist matter more than a listed price. Toptal introduces candidates within 24 hours, runs the trial for you, and can cover design, finance and project management as well as engineering.
The table sets the two side by side on each company’s own pages, read on September 14, 2026. “Not published” means the company gives no figure. For the wider field, see our Toptal alternatives and Arc.dev alternatives pages.
Arc.dev
Toptal
What it sells
Freelance and full-time remote hires
Freelance engagements across engineering, design, finance and project management, plus HireGlobal payroll and EOR
Published prices
$15 to $110+ an hour freelance; 20% of annual salary for a full-time hire
$79 monthly subscription once you proceed; talent rates quoted on a call
Screening
Three rated steps; 2% pass the technical interview
Five stages; fewer than 3% accepted
Speed claim
Freelance hire in 72 hours; full-time in about 14 days
Candidates within 24 hours
If it fails
Freelance trial of up to two weeks; free replacement for three months on full-time
No-risk trial of up to two weeks; up to three trial candidates per position
Network claim
450,000 talent in 190 countries
3,600,000+ cumulative applications by 2025
Track record
800+ hires made
35,000+ clients and 91,000+ engagements by 2025
Billing
Hourly freelance; one-off fee on hire
Weekly price; invoiced twice a month on Net 10
What hiring managers and developers say
Reddit blocked every tool we tried on November 19, 2026, so these themes come from Trustpilot, Clutch and Hacker News threads we opened that day. The reviews section further down has the detail.
Both platforms are reviewed mostly by talent. Toptal’s 4.8 on Trustpilot and Arc’s 4.3 on Trustpilot come mainly from freelancers and developers, not the companies paying them.
Toptal’s clients question price, not quality. On Clutch, cost is Toptal’s weakest score (4.5 against 4.8 for quality), and a 2023 client ended one contract mainly over cost.
Arc’s developers complain about waiting. Its one-star reviews in 2026 describe profiles stuck in review for months; Arc replied that vetting is tied to open roles and had been paused.
Quoted rates hide a margin. A former Toptal consultant on Hacker News in January 2023 said Toptal adds a margin the client never sees on top of the consultant’s rate.
Our take
The price gap is mostly a visibility gap. Arc’s freelance range runs from $15 to $110+ an hour; Clutch places Toptal at $100 to $149. Only Arc’s figure comes from the vendor, so get a Toptal quote before you call it more expensive.
For a permanent hire, Arc is the cheaper structure. A one-off 20% fee ends after the first year’s salary; a Toptal engagement keeps billing weekly for as long as it runs.
Toptal has moved further since 2023. It added payroll, four acquired networks and two AI data businesses. Arc changed its homepage from a job search for developers to a hiring pitch for companies, but kept the same two plans.
How the two screen talent
Both companies publish the share of applicants who survive each stage, so the funnels can sit on one scale. The difference is where each one cuts.
Toptal cuts at the door. Its first stage is an English and communication interview that also assesses personality, and only 26.4% of applicants pass it. An in-depth skill review leaves 7.4%.
A live screening with experts in the candidate’s field leaves 3.6%, and a test project of one to three weeks leaves 3.2%.
Toptal rates the fifth stage, continued excellence, on client work, and puts the end result at 3%. Its screening process page says the whole process takes 3 to 8 weeks.
Arc cuts later. Its how Arc works page says 55% of applicants pass a review of skills, training and experience. An English and remote-readiness check, by live interview or recorded video, leaves 14%.
A one-hour expert interview or pair programming session leaves 2%. A fourth step, the final review, has no pass rate, and Arc says it keeps monitoring talent after they start.
Arc also sources beyond its applicants: open source contributors, top Stack Overflow answerers, and the best of the 350,000+ mentors on Codementor, the mentoring site Arc grew out of.
Read the two percentages with care. Toptal’s 3% is the share accepted into the network. Arc’s 2% is the share who pass the technical interview.
Neither company says how many of those engineers are available in a given week, which is what decides your shortlist.
What each one charges
Arc prices its two plans in different units, and both sit on its pricing page. Freelancers bill by the hour, from $15 to $110+. For a full-time hire, you pay a fee of 20% of the hire’s annual salary, once, and only when you hire.
Candidates set their expected salary, and Arc matches you with candidates inside your range.
The full-time fee is easy to budget. On a $90,000 salary it comes to $18,000, paid on top of pay, with no monthly charge afterwards.
Toptal publishes one fee. Its FAQ describes a flat $79 monthly subscription, charged if you decide to proceed with talent matching. You can cancel at any time, and ask for a refund if Toptal cannot provide talent.
The talent’s own price comes on a call. Toptal’s pricing overview says you can work with talent “hourly, part-, or full- time for a fixed price on a weekly basis”. It invoices twice a month on Net 10 terms.
So you can only compare total cost once you have a Toptal quote for the same role.
Rechecked November 19, 2026. Both price lists were unchanged from September. Arc’s pricing page still shows $15 to $110+ an hour for freelance hires with a risk-free trial of up to two weeks, and 20% of the annual salary for full-time hires. Toptal’s FAQ still lists the $79 subscription, and its pricing page still promises a $0 recruiting fee and no termination costs. Clutch’s profile field puts Toptal at $100 to $149 an hour with a $50,000 minimum project; that is Clutch’s estimate, not a Toptal price.
Speed to a first candidate
Toptal’s speed claim is about the shortlist. Its FAQ says it introduces candidates within 24 hours, and that 90% of clients hire the first candidate it introduces.
Arc’s claims are about the hire. Its homepage says you can hire a freelancer in 72 hours and a full-time employee in about 14 days.
Arc sets that 14 days against 58 days for a typical hiring process, a figure it credits to Workable, where interviews alone take 21 days.
The two claims measure different moments, so do not set 24 hours against 72. Both remove the slow part of hiring: posting a job, collecting CVs and running the first rounds of screening yourself.
When a hire does not work out
Toptal starts each engagement with a trial of up to two weeks. If you are not completely satisfied, you are not billed.
Toptal can then introduce another person for a second no-risk trial, and it allows trials with up to three candidates per position.
Arc’s cover depends on the plan. Freelance hires come with a risk-free trial of up to two weeks.
For full-time hires, Arc says that during the first three months it will match you with another person free of charge if the hire does not suit you.
That is the longest window in this comparison, but it replaces the person rather than refunding the fee.
Network size and track record
Toptal publishes running totals rather than a network size. Its about page counts 3,600,000+ talent applications received by 2025, up from 85,000+ in 2015.
By the same page, it has served 35,000+ clients across 91,000+ engagements, with talent in 155+ countries.
These totals only rise, because they count everything since Toptal started. They show how much the network has grown, not how many experts are available to hire today, and Toptal does not publish that second figure.
Arc gives three different numbers on three pages. The homepage says “450,000 talent in 190 countries” and “800+ hires made”. Its full-time plan mentions a worldwide pool of 20M+ candidates that its HireAI tool can search.
Its about page lists four 2026 acquisitions: QO Collective for management consultants, Adeva for developers, No Single Individual for branding and creative talent, and Graphite for finance and strategy consultants.
Contractor or employee
Toptal talent work with you as contractors on an engagement. For companies that want employees in other countries, Toptal sells HireGlobal, which runs payroll and employer of record contracts.
Toptal says it has processed $5B+ in payroll and payments across 180+ countries, and its “virtual employer of record” model carries $1M of compliance indemnification per worker.
Arc handles both paths inside hiring. Freelancers are paid as contractors.
Full-time hires join your company, either on your own payroll or through an EOR, so the employment contract, benefits and local compliance sit with you or your provider. Our employer of record guides cover what that means market by market.
Reviews: Arc.dev and Toptal side by side
Scores below were read on November 19, 2026. Read them as talent satisfaction more than client satisfaction: on both Trustpilot pages, most recent reviewers are freelancers or developers.
Trustpilot
Clutch
Who writes the reviews
Arc.dev
4.3 on Trustpilot (199 reviews, 13 in the last 12 months)
No Clutch profile we could load
Mostly developers
Toptal
4.8 on Trustpilot (2,586 reviews, 491 in the last 12 months)
4.8 on Clutch (53 client reviews; cost scores lowest at 4.5)
Mostly freelancers on Trustpilot; clients on Clutch
What users say about Arc.dev
Arc’s public reviews come almost entirely from developers. It scores 4.3 on Trustpilot from 199 reviews, but only 13 arrived in the last 12 months.
Of those, ten are five stars: developers in Brazil, Chile, Canada and Thailand praise real contract work, clear communication and a polite team, and one Brazilian developer said it suits part-time contracts if you are patient with the paperwork.
The complaints share one theme: profiles stuck in review. A May 2026 reviewer said vetting had stalled for two years, and a September 2026 reviewer said his profile sat in review with no test or interview. Arc replied to both.
In May it said vetting was paused; in September it said vetting depends on matching open roles. For a client this cuts both ways: the pool you see is the vetted part, not every sign-up.
Client-side discussion is thin. In a February 2023 Hacker News thread on Upwork alternatives, one developer said they were happy working through Arc and Codementor and assumed clients were too.
We found no client review site with enough Arc reviews to report a score.
What users say about Toptal
Toptal’s two review sites tell different stories because different people write them. On Trustpilot, 89% of the 2,586 reviews are five stars and 4% are one star.
Nine of the ten newest reviews on November 19, 2026 read as written by Toptal freelancers praising the matching team, steady clients and on-time pay.
The one client among them said Toptal quickly found two people for a website and sales funnel migration.
Clients review Toptal on Clutch, where it scores 4.8 from 53 reviews. Quality, schedule and willingness to refer all sit at 4.8; cost is the weakest score at 4.5. The comments match the number.
A blockchain client in April 2024 wrote: “They were pricey, but it was definitely worth it.”
A DevOps staffing client spending about $300,000 a year (November 2023) called the rates higher than competitors and ended one contract mainly over cost.
A nonprofit client in January 2024 said the service is not cheap but worth the investment.
Hacker News adds the talent side. In a January 2023 thread, a former Toptal consultant said the consultant sets the rate and Toptal adds a margin the client pays without seeing it, and that recruiters pushed back when he raised his rate.
In a February 2022 Ask HN thread, a client said Toptal’s minimum quote for a PHP developer was about $80 an hour, with quotes seen up to $140, and that the work was good; another commenter, who had both hired and applied, called Toptal expensive with a few weak people slipping through.
Applicants in an August 2016 thread put the screening at roughly 40 hours of their own time.
What changed at Arc.dev and Toptal since 2023
Arc.dev: from job board to hiring pitch
In the June 15, 2023 Wayback capture, Arc’s homepage spoke to developers: “Radically different remote job search where companies apply to you.”
On November 19, 2026 it speaks to buyers: “Hire the world’s top remote talent without the search.” The homepage now leads with HireAI, which screens applicants and contacts matching candidates, and counts 450,000 talent in 190 countries.
The two prices, $15 to $110+ an hour freelance and 20% of salary full time, were the same on September 14 and November 19, 2026.
Toptal: more networks, more products
The Wayback Machine returned errors for toptal.com on both of our tries on November 19, 2026, so this history comes from Toptal’s own about page, which publishes its totals year by year.
Between 2023 and 2025, clients served rose from 25,000+ to 35,000+, engagements from 68,000+ to 91,000+, applications from 2.7 million+ to 3.6 million+, and the countries its talent lives in from 145+ to 155+.
The product changed more than the numbers. Toptal launched HireGlobal for payroll and employment in 2025, then bought four talent networks in 2026.
The same page now lists two AI businesses: ExpertCrowd, which sells RLHF, data labeling and model evaluation powered by Toptal’s network, and Toptal AI, described as a full-stack AI services company.
Its freelance hiring product, the $79 subscription and the two-week trial are unchanged.
Cost example: one senior developer for six months
Six months of full-time work is about 960 hours. The table uses only prices published on this page; the Toptal rows show why a quote matters.
Six months, one senior developer
What you pay
What it rests on
Arc.dev freelance
$14,400 to $105,600+
$15 to $110+ an hour times 960 hours, from Arc’s pricing page
Arc.dev full-time, $90,000 salary
$63,000 plus your payroll costs
$18,000 one-off fee plus six months of salary ($45,000); benefits and employer taxes on top
Toptal
$474 in subscription fees plus the quoted rate
$79 a month for six months; talent rate given on a call
Toptal at Clutch’s listed range
$96,000 to $143,040
Clutch’s $100 to $149 an hour times 960 hours; not a Toptal quote
Second Talent
$23,994 to $35,994
$3,999 to $5,999 a month, all-in, including employment
The Arc full-time row front-loads cost: the $18,000 fee is due when you hire, and the hire is then yours to keep without further platform charges. Over a second year, that structure gets cheaper; a Toptal engagement does not.
Choose Arc.dev if, choose Toptal if
Choose Arc.dev if
You want prices on a page before you talk to anyone
You plan to hire full time and employ the person yourself or through an EOR
You want a three-month free replacement on a full-time hire
Your budget sits at the lower end of freelance rates
Choose Toptal if
You need candidates within 24 hours
You want to trial up to three people without paying for a failed trial
The role is finance, design or project management as well as engineering
You want payroll or EOR from the same vendor, through HireGlobal
By budget. Arc lets you set a salary range and only shows candidates inside it. Toptal quotes per person, so you learn the price after the match.
By speed. Toptal’s 24 hours ends at an introduction; Arc’s 72 hours ends at a freelance hire and its 14 days at a full-time one. If you need a name today, Toptal is quicker; if you need a signed hire this week, both claim it.
By role. Arc covers developers, designers, marketers and product managers. Toptal covers those plus finance experts, project managers and, since 2026, management consultants.
By time zone. Neither publishes an overlap figure. Arc’s talent sits in 190 countries and Toptal’s in 155+, so ask for the hours you need in the brief.
Other options worth a look
Revelo: Latin American engineers on US hours at a published all-in yearly rate.
Upwork: an open marketplace where you see each rate and screen yourself.
Turing: once an Arc and Toptal rival, now an AI training data company.
How we checked. We have followed Arc.dev and Toptal since 2023 as a talent platform in the same market. Prices, guarantees and screening figures come from each company’s own pages, with the read date given where it matters; we rechecked them on November 19, 2026. Review scores were read on Trustpilot and Clutch the same day. Reddit blocked every tool we tried, so user discussion comes from Trustpilot, Clutch and Hacker News threads we opened. The Wayback Machine returned errors for toptal.com, so Toptal’s history uses its own year-by-year totals. We did not sign up for paid trials.
Full-time engineers in Asia with Second Talent
Second Talent vets engineers and employs them for you in nine Asian markets: Vietnam, the Philippines, Indonesia, Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand, Hong Kong, Taiwan and China.
The price is $25 to $39 USD an hour per engineer, billed monthly ($3,999 to $5,999 for 160 hours), all-in, covering sourcing, vetting and our managed EOR.
Our engineers pass four vetting stages: a technical assessment, an AI-native tooling check covering Claude Code, Cursor and Copilot, English at C1 or above, and a behavioral interview.
Search our talent directory yourself or send us a brief. We are engineering first, with a limited non-technical bench in design, sales development, data annotation and operations. Terms are on our pricing page.
Arc is the only one with published rates, so you can price it before a call. A fair comparison needs a Toptal quote for the same role, plus its $79 monthly subscription.
Is Arc the same company as Codementor?
They share a founder, Weiting Liu. Codementor launched in 2014 for coding mentorship, and announced Arc on July 31, 2019.
Which is better for a US startup, Arc.dev or Toptal?
Arc.dev, if you want to see prices first or hire full time with a one-off 20% fee. Toptal, if you want a shortlist within a day and a trial of up to two weeks.
If the role is permanent and you want employment handled too, Second Talent starts at $25 an hour, billed monthly.
Is Arc.dev legit?
Yes. Arc grew out of Codementor, publishes its prices and pass rates, and scores 4.3 on Trustpilot from 199 reviews. Most reviewers are developers; the common complaint is a profile left in review for months.
What are the best alternatives to Toptal for hiring developers?
For published prices, Arc.dev. For Latin America on US hours, Revelo. For choosing on price yourself, Upwork. For a full-time engineer from Asia with employment included, Second Talent. Our Toptal alternatives page compares more.
How fast can I hire a vetted developer?
Toptal says it introduces candidates within 24 hours and typically hires in about 48. Arc says a freelancer in 72 hours and a full-time hire in about 14 days. Second Talent sends 6 to 8 vetted profiles in 24 hours.
What are freelance developer rates in 2026?
Arc’s published range is $15 to $110+ an hour, depending on skill and region. Clutch lists Toptal at $100 to $149. Our freelance developer rate index breaks rates down by stack and region against US rates.
As the Head of International Business at Second Talent, Eric help companies build, manage, and scale their teams across Hong Kong, Southeast Asia, and Taiwan. He leverage my skills in business growth, business development strategy, and new business development to create and execute effective crossborder hiring, EOR and payroll solutions for clients in various industries, such as e-commerce, fintech, and edtech.