TL;DR: Claude Code is the best AI tool for refactoring legacy code in November 2026: in our 19 November test it cleaned up a 168-line legacy Python module in about two minutes for $0.81, all tests still passed, and the slow report ran 74 times faster. GitHub Copilot is the simplest pick, free inside VS Code. For Java or .NET version upgrades, use a recipe tool such as OpenRewrite or AWS Transform.
Two of the five tools we tested for this list in October 2025 have closed self-serve sign-up. Tabnine.com now redirects to its new owner, Tricentis. Google stopped selling Gemini Code Assist on October 9, 2026.
I kept both entries with our old notes, rechecked each price, and added three tools; we ran one of them on a legacy module today.
Quick comparison
Tool
Best for
Paid from
Our test
1. GitHub Copilot
Simple in-editor refactors, Java and .NET upgrades
Free, then $10/mo
Oct 2025
2. Tabnine
Air-gapped enterprise teams
Enterprise only
Oct 2025
3. Gemini Code Assist
Existing subscribers until renewal ends
No new sales
Oct 2025
4. CodeScene
Finding which files to refactor first
€18 per author/mo
Oct 2025
5. Zencoder
Multi-model refactor workflows
$45/mo
Oct 2025
6. Grok Build
Terminal refactors with subagents
Free to try
Not tested
7. Claude Code
Legacy modules with a test suite
$20/mo
19 Nov 2026
8. OpenRewrite / Moderne
Repeatable Java and Spring migrations
Open source core
Not tested
9. AWS Transform
Version upgrades billed per minute
$0.035 per agent minute
Not tested
Key takeaways
1Average cyclomatic complexity in our test module fell from 5.4 to 2.6 per function, and the deepest nesting from 7 levels to 2.
2Microsoft's three Copilot modernization extensions for Java and .NET have 3.3 million VS Code installs between them.
3Amazon Q Developer's Java and .NET transformation ends on April 30, 2027; AWS Transform replaces it.
4CodeScene's own study of 39 codebases found 15 times more defects in low-health code.
79.4M VS Code installs (Chat)2,000 free completions a monthJava, .NET, C++ upgrades
Copilot is the simplest AI refactoring tool for anyone already in VS Code or JetBrains: highlight a function, ask for a cleaner version, and review the diff.
In our October 2025 test it opened each suggestion as a diff instead of overwriting the file, pulled repeated logic into helper functions, split a long function into smaller ones, and offered dictionary lookups and early returns in place of long if-else chains.
The legacy work now has its own product.
Microsoft describes Copilot app modernization as an agent that "analyzes and upgrades Java, .NET, and C++ applications", uses OpenRewrite for API replacements and dependency updates, and scans for CVEs afterwards.
On 19 November we counted 1.90 million VS Code installs for its Java-to-Azure extension, 1.02 million for the Java upgrade extension and 408,421 for the .NET one.
Billing changed on June 1, 2026. The Copilot plans page now meters chat and agent work in GitHub AI Credits (one credit is $0.01), while completions and next edit suggestions use none.
Pro includes 1,000 base credits plus 500 flex credits a month. Our GitHub Copilot review walks through the plans.
Best for: quick, reviewable refactors in the editor, and Java or .NET version upgrades.
Where it struggles: the Free plan gets Auto model selection only, and long agent runs burn credits at API rates.
Price: Free; Pro $10, Pro+ $39, Max $100 a month; Business $19 and Enterprise $39 a seat.
Bought by Tricentis, Jul 30, 20269.7M VS Code installsAir-gapped option
Tabnine is now for one buyer: an enterprise that must keep code on its own servers. Tricentis bought the company on July 30, 2026. tabnine.com now forwards visitors to the Tricentis product page.
Tabnine's own VS Code listing now reads "(Legacy) Tabnine" and says "Tabnine does not onboard new users to this plugin".
The private deployment remains. Tabnine's plans page lists two tiers, Enterprise (SaaS) and Enterprise (private installation), and its deployment docs cover a VPC, on-premises Kubernetes or a fully air-gapped network.
In our October 2025 test, Tabnine let us scope the AI to a file, a folder or the whole workspace, target one function with an @ reference, and link a change to a Jira ticket.
Refactors ran on Gemini 2.5 Pro, Apply showed a diff before writing, and the Test tab produced runnable pytest plans with edge cases such as Unicode strings and empty values.
We had to generate each test one at a time, which slowed bulk work.
Best for: regulated teams already on a Tabnine Enterprise contract.
Where it struggles: no self-serve sign-up, no public price, and the VS Code plugin is in legacy mode.
No new sales since Oct 9, 20261.86 stars, 922 ratings5.7M VS Code installs
Gemini Code Assist only makes sense now if your company already pays for it.
The codeassist.google address forwards to a deprecation notice: since June 18, 2026 the IDE extensions no longer serve the free, Google AI Pro or Google AI Ultra tiers.
Google's sunset page adds that Standard and Enterprise cannot be bought after October 9, 2026, annual auto-renewal ends on January 31, 2027. Monthly renewal ends on December 31, 2027.
Remaining subscribers keep the Gemini 3.x models. Google points other users to Antigravity, whose free tier refreshes a baseline agent quota weekly; our guide to installing Google Antigravity covers the setup.
Our October 2025 notes still describe what existing seats get.
Gemini turned a side-effect-heavy function into a pure one and explained each removed side effect, rewrote old JavaScript to ES6+, and converted React class components to hooks with a bullet list of what replaced componentDidMount.
Its Response Context panel showed which files it had read, and Accept all changes applied a full refactor in one click.
Best for: teams with a Standard or Enterprise seat that runs until 2027.
Where it struggles: no new subscriptions, and the VS Code listing averages 1.86 stars.
Price: not on sale; Antigravity Business is $30 a seat a month.
25+ factors in CodeHealth5 code smells auto-refactored€18 per author a month
CodeScene answers the first question of a legacy refactor: which files first? It scores each file from 1 to 10 on CodeHealth, a metric built from more than 25 factors, then crosses that score with how often your team changes the file.
In our October 2025 test, the Hotspots view lit up the busy, unhealthy modules in dark red, and one drill-down showed a file at a CodeHealth of 3.65 with low test coverage.
The case for doing this comes from CodeScene's own founders. Their Code Red paper studied 39 proprietary production codebases:
15x
more defects in low-quality code
124%
more time to resolve an issue, on average
9x
longer maximum cycle times
Source: Tornhill and Borg, "Code Red: The Business Impact of Code Quality", 39 codebases (authors are CodeScene's founders).
CodeScene now fixes some of what it finds.
Its ACE auto-refactor docs list five smells (Large Method, Deep Nested Logic, Bumpy Road, Complex Conditional, Complex Method) in JavaScript, TypeScript and Java, with a second model that fact-checks each change.
A local CodeHealth MCP server lets an AI agent score its own edits, for €8 a month on the single-user plan.
Best for: deciding where a refactoring budget goes, then guarding the result in pull requests.
Where it struggles: auto-refactor covers three languages, and the VS Code extension has only 37,911 installs.
Price: Standard €18 and Pro €27 per active author a month, billed yearly; free for open source.
BYOK on every plan30,000 credits on Pro4.5 stars, 57 ratings
Zencoder suits teams that want a different model on each step of a refactor.
Its home page now says "Plan with Claude Opus", "Build with Google Gemini" and "Review with OpenAI Codex", and Zenflow Code ships pre-built workflows for features, bugs and refactors. All plans, Free included, accept your own API key.
Zencoder rebuilt its pricing in 2026. The old $19, $49 and $119 tiers are gone; the pricing page now lists Pro at $45, Pro Plus at $95 and Pro Max at $195 a month, with 30,000, 80,000 and 180,000 credits.
Pro Plus adds multi-repository indexing.
Our October 2025 run showed the agent's habits. It wrote a README from the real build scripts, then its unit test agent skipped 12 existing tests and wrote 5 new ones for uncovered helpers.
A palindrome test then failed on an import mismatch. The agent renamed the test file to pytest conventions and re-ran the suite until it passed, asking us to approve each shell command first.
Best for: refactors that need tests written and fixed along the way.
Where it struggles: the entry price is now more than four times Copilot Pro.
Price: Pro $45 ($40 billed yearly), Pro Plus $95, Pro Max $195 a month.
Grok 4.7 model500K token context$2 / $6 per million tokens
Grok Build is xAI's coding agent for engineers who prefer refactoring in the terminal to adopting a new editor.
It runs on Grok 4.7, xAI's newest model, plans multi-file changes, shows edits as diffs, and can split a large refactor across parallel subagents that each work in their own git worktree.
We added Grok after our hands-on round, so the notes below describe its documented features rather than our own test results.
Plan Mode lets you approve, comment on or rewrite the plan before any file changes. The agent reads an AGENTS.md file, supports skills, hooks, plugins and MCP servers, and runs headless in scripts and CI.
xAI opened it as an early beta for SuperGrok and X Premium+ subscribers on May 25, 2026; the build page now says it is available to try for free.
On the API, the xAI models page prices Grok 4.7 at $2 in and $6 out per million tokens for prompts under 200,000 tokens, and $4 and $12 above that. Its 500,000-token window keeps more of a large codebase in view during a restructure.
Subscriptions moved to The X Subscription on October 12, 2026, where Premium at $30 a month includes the old SuperGrok benefits. Our guide to every Grok model compares the rest of the family.
Best for: terminal-first teams splitting a big modernization across subagents.
Where it struggles: long prompts over 200,000 tokens cost twice the base rate.
Price: free to try; X Subscription Premium $30, Super $100 a month; API $2 / $6 per million tokens.
7. Claude Code
119 s for the full refactor8 of 8 tests passing30.6M VS Code installs
Claude Code is Anthropic's coding agent for handing over a whole refactor and reviewing the result. It runs in a terminal, VS Code, JetBrains, a desktop app or the web, and defaults to Claude Opus 5.5 on all paid plans.
We tested it ourselves on 19 November 2026, on Claude Code 2.1.328.
The test subject was a 168-line Python billing module we wrote to look like code patched for a decade: three near-identical pricing functions, if-else chains seven levels deep, mutable globals, a linear customer search inside the order loop, and a report that rescanned all orders once per customer.
Eight unit tests passed before we started, and a benchmark ran the report on 10,000 orders and 1,000 customers.
We ran Claude Code headless from the project folder with claude -p "<prompt>" --output-format json --permission-mode acceptEdits, allowing only file tools, the test command and the benchmark. The exact prompt:
Refactor src/billing.py. It is legacy code with duplicated pricing logic, deep nesting, module-level mutable globals and slow nested loops. Goals: remove the duplication, flatten the nesting, make the hot path (build_report) fast on 10,000+ orders, and keep the module easy to read. Constraints: keep every public function name and signature (load_customers, find_customer, calc_gold, calc_silver, calc_basic, process_orders, build_report, reset) and keep the output of every function identical, including the running totals and error list that reset() clears. Do not edit anything in tests/ or bench.py. Before you finish, run `python -m unittest discover -s tests` and `python bench.py`, and make sure all tests pass and the sha256 that bench.py prints is still d0adfc9b6cb0390b8c66e19723d3843eccb24a2faa32637658a6a260b2483631. Reply with a short summary of what you changed.
The run took 119 seconds over 13 turns and cost $0.81 at list price, according to the JSON it returned (8,212 output tokens).
It replaced the three pricing functions with one-line wrappers around a shared function driven by a table of discount bands, swapped the nested checks for early exits, and indexed customers in a dictionary built once per call.
It kept a detail we had not mentioned: zero rates stay the integer 0, so a whole-number price does not turn into a float.
We measured the code with radon 6.0.1 before and after.
Source lines fell from 149 to 98, and the maintainability index rose from 32.1 to 57.3. find_customer and load_customers kept their complexity of 3 and 2, because the prompt froze their signatures and find_customer still does a linear search for callers outside the module.
The report itself went from a median of 1,294 milliseconds to 17 over 15 runs each, about 74 times faster, with a byte-identical SHA-256 of the output.
To check beyond our own tests, we ran a fuzz script against the original on 375,165 pricing inputs plus four stateful batches, and all values matched.
The one difference was cosmetic: calc_basic(-0.0) now returns 0.0 instead of -0.0, a case build_report cannot reach because it rejects amounts of zero or below.
One behaviour is worth knowing before you script it. Claude Code tried five times to run its own equivalence check, which our allow-list blocked, and its summary said the check had not run.
Best for: legacy modules that have tests, where you can state the constraints in one prompt.
Where it struggles: no free plan, and it will try commands you did not allow unless you script the permissions.
Price: Pro $20 a month ($17 billed yearly), Max $100, Ultra $200; Team from $25 a seat.
8. OpenRewrite and Moderne
v8.111.0, Nov 18, 20263,994 GitHub starsApache 2.0 core
OpenRewrite is for the refactor you must repeat across hundreds of repositories, where an AI guess per file is too risky.
It is an open-source refactoring engine that applies deterministic "recipes" to a Lossless Semantic Tree, so it keeps your formatting. Its Java 21 guide runs one recipe, UpgradeToJava21, from Maven, Gradle or the Moderne CLI.
The licence has shifted. The core stays Apache 2.0, but newer recipe modules use the Moderne Source Available License, and the Java 21 page says "Compiled binaries are only available to Moderne customers".
Moderne, the company behind it, sells the platform that runs recipes across a whole code estate; its pricing page puts a typical Commercial deal near $250,000 for up to about 1,000 developers.
Copilot's modernization agent calls OpenRewrite under the hood.
Best for: Java, Spring Boot and Kotlin upgrades that must land the same way across repositories.
Where it struggles: no help with business-logic cleanup, and the newest recipes need a Moderne account.
Price: open source core; Moderne platform by quote.
9. AWS Transform
$2.52 for a 17,000-line Java upgrade50,000 free .NET minutes a month
AWS Transform is the closest thing to an AI code refactoring service you pay by the minute.
The custom agent handles Java, Python and Node.js version upgrades, AWS SDK migrations and moves such as JBoss to Spring Boot, and you can start it from Kiro, Claude Code, Cursor or VS Code.
The pricing page charges $0.035 per agent minute, counted only while the agent plans, reasons or edits. Its worked example upgrades about 17,000 lines of Java in about 72 minutes for $2.52.
Managed .NET transformation is free up to 50,000 agent minutes a month. AWS claims "up to 85% efficacy" on its out-of-the-box transformations, a figure we did not test.
It is also where Amazon Q Developer users have to go. AWS's end-of-support notice blocked new Q Developer sign-ups from May 15, 2026 and ends the IDE plugins on April 30, 2027.
Best for: version upgrades on AWS where a per-minute bill beats a seat.
Where it struggles: built around AWS accounts and AWS-shaped migrations.
Price: $0.035 per agent minute; assessment and .NET up to the cap are free.
Which AI tool is best for refactoring legacy code?
Claude Code, if the module has tests: the tests let an agent change a lot of code without breaking it. Developers spend 42% of their time fixing bugs, by Unqork's count.
Measure first, write tests where none exist, then hand the agent one module at a time. Version upgrades are a different job, better done by recipes than by a model.
For an AI code optimizer, the gain in our test came from the data structures, not from micro-tuning: one dictionary and one set removed two nested loops.
Ask the agent to name the complexity of the hot path before and after, then check it with a benchmark of your own.
How we collected this data. On 19 November 2026 we read install counts from the Visual Studio Marketplace gallery API (extensionquery, api-version 7.2-preview.1, flags 914, filterType 7 by extension ID) and the JetBrains Marketplace API, and stars and releases from the GitHub API. The Claude Code test used radon 6.0.1 for complexity, Python's unittest for the 8 tests, and the median of 15 timed runs of build_report on 10,000 generated orders (seed 42). Prices and plan terms come from each vendor's own pages that day.
Hire engineers who can run a refactor
The nine tools above still need someone who writes the characterization tests and rejects a bad diff.
GitHub Copilot Free is the simplest: install it in VS Code, highlight a function and ask for a refactor; it shows a diff before applying and includes 2,000 completions a month.
Are there AI code refactoring services rather than tools?
AWS Transform bills per agent minute for upgrades and migrations, and Moderne sells OpenRewrite-based migrations across a whole code estate. Both suit planned upgrade campaigns more than day-to-day cleanup.
Which AI coding agent should I compare these with?
Our ranking of coding agents for VS Code compares Copilot, Claude Code, Codex, Cline and Kilo Code on approvals and price.
Get developers who ship with AI agents. Starts at $25/Hour.
Matt Li is a tech-driven entrepreneur with deep expertise in global talent strategy, digital experience optimization, e-commerce, and Web3 innovation.
He is the Co-Founder of Second Talent, a US-based company that connects businesses with top-tier tech professionals worldwide. Since launching the company in 2024, Matt has led its growth by leveraging technology to streamline remote hiring and scale distributed teams.
With a background spanning product, operations, and innovation, Matt brings a cross-disciplinary perspective to the evolving digital economy. His work sits at the intersection of global talent, emerging technology, and scalable digital transformation.