Skip to content

Gemini vs ChatGPT Tested: 7 Tasks, Plans, Prices (Nov 2026)

Matt Li By Matt Li, Co-Founder and Director 13 min read
Gemini vs ChatGPT: Second Talent's seven-task hands-on test of Google's and OpenAI's chatbots, November 2026.
TL;DR: ChatGPT's free plan was the more dependable of the two in our seven tests, answering every prompt on the first try, while Gemini 4 Hydrogen Thinking needed a second attempt on three of them. Gemini wrote the sharper bug diagnosis and lives inside Gmail, Docs and Drive, so it suits teams already paying for Google Workspace; ChatGPT wins on fast, sourced answers and for anyone outside Google's suite. Paid entry plans cost the same: $19.99 a month for Google AI Pro against $20 for ChatGPT Plus.

Asked who won the 2026 World Cup final, Gemini replied "Winner & Score: Unavailable", because web search was down. The same question in a new chat came back right, with five sources.

ChatGPT's free plan got it right on the first try in about 20 seconds.

That was one of three Gemini answers on 22 November 2026 that needed a retry. For a tool a whole team leans on, I count a stalled reply against it more than a less polished answer, so this comparison leads with reliability.

Key takeaways
  1. 1Both password checkers rated Password123! as Strong: neither tool's code looks for common passwords.
  2. 2ChatGPT Free, Go, Plus and Pro use your chats for training unless you opt out; Google says Workspace chats are not used without permission.
  3. 3On the API, OpenAI's GPT-6 Luna costs $0.50 per million output tokens, 15 times less than Gemini 4 Hydrogen.
  4. 4Google AI Pro needs a personal Google account; on a work account, Gemini comes with the Workspace plan instead.

Is Gemini or ChatGPT Better? Our Seven-Test Scorecard

ChatGPT Free passed all seven tests on the first attempt. Gemini passed all seven too, but three only after a retry: one answer came without web search, and two prompts hung with a spinner and no reply.

Once it did answer, Gemini was the more precise of the two on the debugging task. The two tied on maths, JSON and refusing to invent a paper.

Heatmap of Second Talent's seven hands-on tests, 17 and 22 November 2026. ChatGPT Free passes the fact-check, maths, JSON and fake-paper tests outright and passes the password checker, sort bug and job post with a flaw. Gemini 4 Hydrogen Thinking passes the sort bug and fake-paper tests, passes the password checker and job post with a flaw, and passes the fact-check, maths and JSON tests only on a retry.

"Pass, with a flaw" marks an answer that did the job with a defect a careful reader would catch. The flaws are listed test by test below.

Gemini setup
  • gemini.google.com, signed in with a Google Workspace business account
  • Model picker: "Complex problems: 4 Hydrogen Thinking"
  • All seven tests on 22 November 2026
ChatGPT setup
  • chatgpt.com, signed in on the Free plan
  • Default model; the chat window showed no model name
  • Tests 1 and 2 on 17 November, tests 3 to 7 on 22 November 2026

Both ran in Chrome on Windows 11 from Southeast Asia. The other choices in Gemini's picker were "Everyday help" (4 Hydrogen) and "Detailed research" (3.1 Pro).

We did not confirm which Workspace edition the account maps to, so the results describe that account, not a named plan.

TestGemini 4 Hydrogen ThinkingChatGPT Free
1. Password checkerWorks, about 115 s; Password123! StrongWorks, about 10 s; Password123! Strong
2. Sort bugCorrect, explains why oldest orders surviveCorrect, vaguer on why, about 8 s
3. Fact-checkNo search on try 1; correct on try 2Correct, three FIFA sources, about 20 s
4. MathsHung twice; 276 on try 3, about 66 s276, first try
5. Job postRules kept, 95 words; title and pay ran togetherRules kept, 88 words; added a line nobody asked for
6. JSONHung once; valid on re-run, about 41 sValid, first try
7. Fake paperRefused to invent; said it could not searchSearched, could not verify, asked for a DOI

Coding: A Password Checker and a Sort Bug

Test 1: Both Checkers Call Password123! Strong

Gemini: about 115 sChatGPT: about 10 sCommon-password check: neither

Gemini opened a Canvas panel with Code, Preview and Export buttons and built the page with Tailwind CSS: a "Set a password" card, a three-segment bar and five requirement rows.

ChatGPT put one HTML file in a code block with a preview inside the chat: a four-segment bar, five checks and a show/hide toggle.

The two pages scored our four passwords the same way. "abc" was Weak. "abcDef7" was Medium on both, although it is seven characters with no symbol. The 14-character "abcDef7!xyzQ9k" was Strong.

So was "Password123!", one of the first strings an attacker tries.

Screenshot of the password strength checker Gemini built in Canvas: a Set a password card with Password123! typed in, all three bar segments green, the label Strong and all five requirements ticked. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

Claude's free model, Sonnet 5.5, was the one tool in our runs that rated Password123! as Weak; our Claude vs ChatGPT coding test has that result. Between these two, ChatGPT's ten-second turnaround is the difference you would notice.

Test 2: Gemini Explains the Sort Bug Better

Root cause: both rightWhy the oldest orders: Gemini only

JSON has no date type, so a.date - b.date subtracts two strings and returns NaN. Both tools found that.

Gemini went one step further and named the mechanism: the sort treats NaN as "equal", so the array keeps its API order, and when the API sends a customer's orders newest first, the push-and-shift loop keeps the three oldest.

Screenshot of Gemini's answer to the latestOrders debugging prompt: under The Bug it says JSON has no Date type, subtracting two date strings gives NaN, sort treats NaN as equal and keeps API order, and newest-first API order makes shift() keep the 3 oldest orders. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

Its fix sorted a copy with new Date().getTime(), warned about timestamps stored in Unix seconds, and swapped a ||= lookup for Object.hasOwn to guard against prototype keys.

ChatGPT answered in about 8 seconds with a correct fix that sorts newest first on a copy, but said only that the sort "becomes unreliable".

For code review, I would pick Gemini's answer: it tells you why the bug hit some customers and not others.

Our Gemini vs Claude coding comparison runs the same two prompts against Claude.

Fact-Checking and Hallucination Resistance

Test 3: The World Cup Final

Spain beat Argentina 1-0 after extra time on 19 July 2026 at MetLife Stadium, which FIFA called New York New Jersey Stadium, with Ferran Torres scoring in the 106th minute, per ESPN's match report.

Gemini's first try showed a "Searching the web" spinner, then answered without search. It gave the stadium and the date, wrote "Winner & Score: Unavailable", and pointed to a FIFA schedule page from 2024 as its source.

Screenshot of Gemini's first answer to who won the 2026 FIFA World Cup final: it names MetLife Stadium and 19 July 2026 but says web search is currently unavailable and lists Winner and Score as Unavailable. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

Gemini left the winner blank instead of guessing, which is the right way to fail. A new chat got the full answer with search, plus extra match detail, citing FIFA.com, Google Sports, MLS, FOX Sports and Wikipedia.

ChatGPT searched without being asked and answered in about 20 seconds: score card with flags, date, stadium under both names, East Rutherford, Torres in the 106th minute.

It listed three FIFA pages: the match report, the champions announcement and the fixtures list.

Screenshot of ChatGPT Free answering the World Cup final question: a Spain 1, Argentina 0 score card, then 19 July 2026, New York New Jersey Stadium (MetLife Stadium), East Rutherford, Ferran Torres in the 106th minute, and three FIFA sources. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

Test 7: A Paper That Does Not Exist

Invented findings: neitherSearched: ChatGPT

Neither tool made up findings. ChatGPT searched, wrote "I couldn't verify the existence of the 2024 paper", explained in three bullets why nothing could be attributed to it, and asked for a DOI, PDF or URL.

Gemini showed "Searching the web" again, then said it could not verify the paper and "cannot search for it externally right now".

It offered to summarise the abstract if pasted and named three real routing papers instead: DeepSeekMoE, ReMoE and Expert Choice Routing.

Screenshot of Gemini asked to summarise a 2024 paper that does not exist: it says it cannot verify or summarise the paper and cannot search for it externally right now, then offers to summarise a pasted abstract or real papers such as DeepSeekMoE, ReMoE or Expert Choice Routing. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

Both answers pass. Gemini's also confirms the pattern from test 3: on 22 November, its search tool failed more than once in our session, and it said so each time rather than covering the gap.

Not every chatbot does; ByteDance's Dola listed three findings for the same fake paper in our Dola AI review.

Maths, Writing to Rules and Structured Output

Test 4: Bug-Count Maths

Both reached 276. ChatGPT split it by period: 72 + 12 = 84 bugs in weeks one and two, then 4 x 12 x 4 = 192 for the last four weeks.

Gemini split it by person: 216 from the original three, 12 and 48 from the new hire, rendered as typeset maths.

Gemini took three tries. The first two hung with a spinner and no answer after more than 100 seconds each, and we stopped them. The third, in a fresh chat, answered in about 66 seconds.

Test 5: A Job Post With Strict Rules

Gemini: 95 wordsChatGPT: 88 wordsExact last line: both

Both kept every rule: under 120 words, exactly three requirement bullets, no emojis, and the closing line "Apply via Second Talent." with its closing period. Each had one defect.

Gemini's title ran straight into its pay line with no break, so the post opens on one long bold line ending in "Compensation:". That is a paste-and-fix job, not a rewrite.

Screenshot of Gemini's job post for a remote Senior React Developer in Vietnam: the bold title runs straight into the Compensation line, followed by one paragraph and exactly three requirement bullets. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

ChatGPT laid the post out in a Writing panel and added "Employment Type: Full-time", which the prompt never said. Invented terms in a job ad are the riskier mistake, because they read as an offer.

Both also used a dash in the salary range where the prompt wrote "to".

Screenshot of ChatGPT Free's job post in a Writing panel: Salary, Location and an unrequested Employment Type: Full-time line, a short paragraph, three requirement bullets and the closing line Apply via Second Talent. Second Talent test, 22 November 2026.

Test 6: JSON Only

Both returned a pretty-printed array with no code fence and no commentary, and every value was right: Hanoi, VND, +07:00; Manila, PHP, +08:00; Jakarta, IDR, +07:00; Kuala Lumpur, MYR, +08:00.

Gemini's reply passed JSON.parse on the re-run, about 41 seconds in, after the first attempt hung. ChatGPT's came back valid on the first try.

Which Models You Get on Each Plan

Google names three Gemini 4 models on its US subscriptions page: Hydrogen, Neon and Carbon. OpenAI's ChatGPT pricing page lists the GPT-6 family (Luna, Sol, Astra) and GPT-5.6 models plan by plan. Read on 22 November 2026:

PlanModels listed
Gemini FreeAuto model selection
Google AI PlusGemini 4 Hydrogen
Google AI ProGemini 4 Neon and 4 Hydrogen
Google AI UltraHighest access to Gemini 4 Carbon, Neon and Hydrogen
ChatGPT Free and GoGPT-6 Luna, GPT-5 Thinking Mini
ChatGPT PlusAdds GPT-6.1 Sol, GPT-6 Sol, GPT-6 Astra and the GPT-5.6 models
ChatGPT ProExpanded GPT-6 use, unlimited GPT-5.6 Sol, plus GPT-5.6 Sol Pro

Our Workspace account offered 4 Hydrogen, 4 Hydrogen Thinking and 3.1 Pro, a set that matches none of the consumer rows above.

ChatGPT never named its model in the chat window, so the Free plan entry is OpenAI's listing, not something we saw on screen. Our guide to every Gemini model and guide to every OpenAI model cover each model's history.

Free Tier Limits

Neither company publishes a fixed message count for its free tier. Google says Gemini app limits are compute-based: they depend on prompt complexity, the features used and chat length, refresh every 5 hours and stop at a weekly cap.

Google AI Plus doubles the free allowance and Pro quadruples it.

OpenAI offers "unlimited text chats" on Free, subject to abuse guardrails, with limited uploads, image creation, deep research and Codex.

The tighter limit is context: the Free plan's Instant model holds 27K tokens, about 12 pages of input, against 54K on Go and Plus. Google's FAQ puts a 1M-token context window on AI Pro.

Paid Plans and Prices

The consumer ladders line up almost price for price, and the business seats do not. US list prices on 22 November 2026, from Google's subscriptions page, the Google Workspace pricing page and OpenAI's pricing docs:

Google AI Plusper month
$4.99
2x free usage, 400 GB storage. ChatGPT Go is $8 and may show ads.
Google AI Proper month
$19.99
4x free usage, 5 TB storage. ChatGPT Plus is $20.
Google AI Ultraper month
$99.99 or $199.99
5x or 20x Pro usage. ChatGPT Pro is $100, $200 or $500.
Business seatsper user, monthly billing
$14 vs $25
Workspace Business Standard with Gemini vs ChatGPT Business ($20 billed yearly).

The business row compares different products. $14 buys a whole Workspace seat: email, 2 TB of storage, Meet and Gemini in Gmail, Docs and Meet. $25 buys ChatGPT alone.

Workspace Business Starter at $7 includes the Gemini app but, per Google's feature table, not "Google's most capable AI models for complex tasks". Gemini Enterprise, sold separately for $30 a seat, adds connectors to Microsoft 365.

Google AI Pro and Ultra also need "a personal Google Account that you manage on your own", so a company on Workspace buys Gemini through the Workspace plan, not through AI Pro.

API Prices per Million Tokens

OpenAI is cheaper at the bottom of the range and dearer at the top. GPT-6 Luna, the model OpenAI lists for ChatGPT Free, costs $0.10 per million input tokens on the API.

Gemini 4 Hydrogen costs $1.50 in and $7.50 out, and the Gemini API's free tier lets you try it at no cost.

Split bar chart of API list prices per million tokens, input against output, standard paid tier, read 22 November 2026: GPT-6 Luna $0.10 and $0.50, Gemini 4 Hydrogen $1.50 and $7.50, GPT-6.2 Sol $2 and $10, Gemini 3.1 Pro $2 and $12, Gemini 4 Neon $3 and $15, GPT-6.2 Astra $8 and $40.

Prices are the Standard paid tier on Google AI Studio's pricing page and OpenAI's API pricing page. Google counts thinking tokens as output.

OpenAI doubles input prices past 272K input tokens; Gemini 3.1 Pro rises to $4 in and $18 out past 200K. Google's Gemini 4 Carbon lists $2 in and $10 out until 30 November 2026, then $4 and $20.

Privacy and Data Use for Business Accounts

On business plans, both companies promise not to train on your data by default. On personal plans, both do unless you change a setting.

Gemini on Workspace
  • Customer data not used for training without permission
  • Gemini app chats not reviewed by humans
  • SOC 1/2/3, ISO/IEC 27001 and 42001, FedRAMP High
ChatGPT Business and Enterprise
  • No training on business data by default
  • Retention configurable for qualifying organisations
  • SOC 2 Type 2, ISO/IEC 27001, AES-256 at rest

Google sets this out in its Workspace generative AI privacy hub, and our Gemini window carried the same promise in its footer: the organisation's chats "aren't used to improve our models". OpenAI's terms are on its business data page.

The personal tiers differ. ChatGPT Free, Go, Plus and Pro mark "Content is used to train our models" with an opt-out.

Google's Gemini Apps privacy hub says personal chats train its models while History is on, that a subset is read by human reviewers, and that reviewed chats are kept for up to three years.

A teammate on a personal account of either tool is not covered by the business promise.

Google Workspace vs ChatGPT's Apps: Where Each One Plugs In

Gemini's advantage is placement. On Workspace Business Standard and above it sits inside Gmail, Docs, Sheets, Slides, Drive, Meet and Chat.

If your team already writes in Docs and mails from Gmail, the assistant is there without a second subscription.

ChatGPT reaches into other suites instead. ChatGPT for PowerPoint is an add-in on every plan, Free included, that builds and edits slides from notes or spreadsheets.

On Business, Enterprise and Edu, @ChatGPT joins Slack and Microsoft Teams channels. A company on Microsoft 365 gets more from that than from Gemini, short of paying $30 a seat for Gemini Enterprise.

Which Should You Use?

Pick by where your team works and what it asks most often. Based on our runs and the pricing pages:

  • Your company runs on Google Workspace: Gemini. It is already in the seat you pay for, and the business data terms cover it.
  • Debugging and code review: Gemini, for the clearer root-cause explanation in test 2; expect slower builds than ChatGPT.
  • Quick fact-checks with sources: ChatGPT. It searched unprompted, cited FIFA and did not stall.
  • Structured output in a pipeline: ChatGPT on the app, and GPT-6 Luna on the API if cost decides it.
  • A team on Microsoft 365 or Slack: ChatGPT Business, for the Teams, Slack and PowerPoint hooks.
  • A free tool for one person: ChatGPT Free answered every prompt first time. We did not test Gemini's consumer free plan.

For a three-way view with Claude's paid models, see our GPT-6 vs Claude vs Gemini comparison.

Hiring Developers Who Work With Both

The gap between these tools showed up in review, not in typing: both shipped a password checker that waves through Password123!. Engineers who catch that are the ones worth hiring.

Second Talent places vetted remote engineers across Asia, including React developers like the one our test job post described. Tell us who you need.

FAQ

Is Gemini free to use?

Yes. Gemini's free plan needs only a Google account and includes Deep Research and Canvas, with limits that refresh every 5 hours up to a weekly cap. Our tests ran on a Workspace business account, not the consumer free plan.

Which ChatGPT model is on the Free plan?

OpenAI's pricing page lists GPT-6 Luna and GPT-5 Thinking Mini for Free. The chat window did not show a model name during our tests.

Can I buy Google AI Pro on a work email?

No. Google says AI Pro needs a personal Google account; a work account gets Gemini through its Google Workspace plan or Gemini Enterprise.

Did Gemini make anything up in your tests?

No. When search failed, Gemini said so and left the answer blank rather than guess, and it refused to summarise the fake paper. Its weak point was replies that stalled, not replies that made things up.

Get developers who ship with AI agents. Starts at $25/Hour.

Start Hiring $0 cost until you hire
Matt Li

Written by

Matt Li is a tech-driven entrepreneur with deep expertise in global talent strategy, digital experience optimization, e-commerce, and Web3 innovation. He is the Co-Founder of Second Talent, a US-based company that connects businesses with top-tier tech professionals worldwide. Since launching the company in 2024, Matt has led its growth by leveraging technology to streamline remote hiring and scale distributed teams. With a background spanning product, operations, and innovation, Matt brings a cross-disciplinary perspective to the evolving digital economy. His work sits at the intersection of global talent, emerging technology, and scalable digital transformation.

More posts by Matt Li →